Lindsay Lorraine’s plans for her family’s Higgins Beach cottage were anything but the usual. Though it was a second home, Lindsay and her husband Shaun knew from the outset that they wanted to make it into something far beyond your typical vacation retreat.
In part thanks to Lindsay’s lifelong connection to the area, the couple had ambitious plans to make it into a second home with first-home style and functionality. “I grew up in South Portland,” she says, “and grew up going to Higgins Beach my whole life.” She and Shaun had been renting a weekend bungalow in the area when they had their son in 2013. “Our other house was in New York, but our hearts were here,” she reflects. “And we thought, ‘How can we make Maine a bigger part of our family routine?’”
The Higgins Beach cottage they bought soon after had just the square footage they were looking for, a beautiful backyard, and proximity to the ocean. After moving in, they took their time deciding how they ultimately wanted to live on the property. “We knew the kitchen wasn’t working for us,” Lindsay says. “And there was a really big bathroom upstairs, but it wasn’t efficient. There was a basement that could’ve made a great kids’ playroom, but it wasn’t finished.” Moreover, she says, there was the overall feel. “We didn’t want anything too precious,” she says.“We wanted a place where no one’s worried about wet feet. Where everyone’s so comfortable, they want to be here as much as possible.”
Enter Jessica Jolin, principal architect at Mobile Studio Design in Biddeford, and interior designer Jade Cunningham of New York. The first order of business was to help the family decide whether to renovate or tear down and rebuild. The local character-based zoning code presented lots of limits on newly built residences. And so? “To prevent moving the house away from the street and the water views,” Jessica explains, “the family decided to retain the existing footprint and general massing.”
And so the mission became clear: To renovate the same building into a place that felt as easygoing and airy as a beach house but functioned as efficiently as a primary residence—one that accommodated the family’s flow, could get a little messy, feel lived in, and as a result, get used all the time.
The structural process, which took eight months to design and about a year to build, entailed verylittle expansion of the house. “The only thing that was extended was the rear, for the kitchen,” says Leah Schaffer, project architect at Mobile Studio Design. “Other than that, it was about playing around with existing space.” That meant modulating the windows to open things up, and reimagining the staircase area. “We left the stairs in the same spot, but reconfigured it to have a fully open railing system so the house didn’t feel so enclosed,” she says. “We realized we could change a few step locations and remove the walls and make it as see-through as we could.”
Upstairs, they moved the large bathroom and expanded an office space to become one of the children’s bedrooms, effectively consolidating the family quarters on the second floor, and making more room for guests elsewhere. And the aforementioned basement was finished and saw a half bath added, resulting in a play space and more sleeping options.
That said, the home’s overall aesthetic—from materials to color palette—would need to mirror its new flow and functionality.
“When Lindsay said in the first phone call that she wanted a family house that embodied the style of ‘Scandinavian-Montauk,’ I knew it would be a fun project,” recalls Jessica. “[She] wanted everything to feel fresh and light, but have classic cottage elements like black windows and cedar-wrapped shingles. With such young children, sand, and water we thought her color choices were very brave!”
Of course, having an interior designer who’s also a dear friend with longtime knowledge of the family doesn’t hurt when it comes to facing down such challenges. “I knew this was a house to stay in the family for generations,” Jade explains. “So the design needed to be kept timeless. Nothing too trendy, so it felt light and spacious but not overdone.”
And it would need to be able to stand up to regular use. Jade leaned into that balance with layers of neutral-toned, natural elements made of user-friendly materials. For example, the new kitchen’s delicate-looking white quartz counters, set against warm wood and a handmade zellige tile backsplash. “But actually,” —reveals Lindsay— “those counters are so hardy, we can cut limes directly on them.”
Asked about the final result, Lindsay concludes, “We spend time here in all the seasons and when we’re here we feel lighter and more relaxed, yet rooted. This amazing team helped us create a home that evokes that very feeling.”